I guess there are a couple of viewpoints

First off, my comment was meant only in relationship to interviews, not ongoing performance reviews (which I also think are useless, but for other reasons).

I think the “what are your weaknesses” question in an interview situation is one of those bullsh!tty questions that doesn’t really add value to the interview - people look for ways to dodge it, or get screwed if they answer truthfully. So my attitude is to dodge it but try to be open and honest about the way I’m dodging it.

I guess it depends on the tone of the interview and who’s doing the questioning. If it’s a “personnel jockey” then it’s a weasel question. If it’s the hiring manager doing the asking it’s worthwhile either considering whether it’s a genuine question deserving of the best answer you can give, or if the hiring manager is not the kind of person you want to work for.

Btw the reason I think performance reviews are bull is that they are generally used to justify not giving someone a pay raise, rather than be used to review the individuals performance honestly. They certainly have the potential to be useful, but sadly they’re rarely used that way.

Thanks for the comment!
amd.

Right now, it’s an emerging practice for reviews to ask a candiate’s boss or direct reports about his/her weaknesses. So, what happens if you show up to your performance interview and say one thing, but your review says, “Well, from my observation (or your boss/direct reports tell me), one of your opportunties is….”

For me, the best way to approach the weakness question is to find from your boss, direct reports, and peers and ask them what your STRENGTHS are and what they think your WEAKNESSES are as well. Get honest feedback. Hopefully, they you should reciprocate because you all we be reviewed sometime in your career. With a list of 2-3 strengths and 2-3 weaknesses, you then need to identify how your STRENGTHS compensate for your WEAKNESSES.

Now I’m in the position where I review dozens of managers quarterly (not just annual review in my company). I know when someone is giving me the BS they think I want to hear, but their raise, promotion, etc. is hindered by their answers. When I find somone who is able to say, “My weakness is …, but I am using my strengths in …. to compensate for them,” I am able to ask follow up questions and understand what this person’s strengths are and how they are using them to compensate for their weaknesses. In my opinion, that is the whole point of the questions — identify your weaknesses and state how your strengths are compensating for them.

I know this is my preference, and your reviewers may not have the same opinion; however, if you want really good published advice, I highly recommend “Soaring on Your Strengths” by Robin Ryan and “NOW: Discover your Strengths” by Marcus Buckingham.